Keurig 1.0 vs 2.0 — Which One Is Right For You?

Last updated:
keurig 1.0 vs 2.0

Many people found out the hard way what the differences are between these two similar lines of coffee makers. 

Significant underlying differences force us coffee lovers to make some pretty hard choices. Unfortunately, we can’t have it all, and you will have to draw the line somewhere.

We know and love the Keurigs because they have the advanced features to quickly make one cup of amazing coffee. It’s the main reason we are drawn to them in the first place, and both deliver on that. 

But from there, each line goes its separate way, and choosing between one of the Keurig 1.0s or one of the Keurig 2.0s will be a personal decision. 

This caused a lot of drama in the coffee industry. Keurig has been accused of taking advantage of its customers and being greedy with its newfound fame and success. We’ll let you decide after reading this article. 

Right now, avid coffee drinkers are split down the middle when it comes to Keurig equipment. Have a look at all the information below to decide which side of the fence you land on. 

Understanding A Keurig

keurig models

The first thing to note is that these are different machines than you may be used to. They have a lot of programmable features, which is why it’s so easy to use. 

  • All Keurigs are built to brew one cup of coffee. This is their main draw, so people don’t have to brew a whole pot and then watch it get cold, stale, bitter, or all three. 
  • All Keurigs are made to be fast. They brew quickly, which appeals to the working class, who are busy with a lot of other things each and every morning. 
  • All Keurigs look stunning. The word ‘Keurig’ is dutch for ‘excellence,’ and that’s what you get in styling and programmable functions. Even though these coffee brewers do different things, they do them very well.  

A Brief History 

It started just like any other great idea. John Sylvan and Peter Dragone noticed an inefficiency and wanted to provide a solution.  

Initially, they designed a commercial coffee machine product line for office and workplace use. These moderately successful machines were enough to catch the eye of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, who became a primary investor. After extensive trial and error, they released a machine that was an instant hit.  

Everything was running smoothly as they sold tens of millions of single-serve coffee makers. In 2014, Keurig would release the 2.0 machines and disrupt their operations forever.    

Keurig 1.0Keurig 2.0
FeaturesSimpler operating proceduresControl over water temperature and brew-strength
Third-party K Cups compatibilityYesMostly no
SizeBulkier in sizeSmaller in size
Control panelControl panel with few buttonsDigital control panel
PriceMore affordableMore pricey

Keurig 1.0

As the machine that started it all back in 1998, it has not lost any popularity. It is still found in millions of homes around the world. This coffee maker model changed the way people start their day and has made it easier to try new coffee flavors all at the touch of a button. 

We did not know what K-cup pods were until they ushered in a whole new way of brewing coffee. This simple invention has catapulted the Keurig 1.0 to stardom—not having to fuss with home-ground coffees and getting the proper ratios turned out to be just what coffee addicts wanted. 

This Is A Massive Feature Of The Keurig 1.0

The 1.0 also has reusable coffee pods for people like me who still want to grind their own beans. While I admit this is more time-consuming, I can be stubborn. This is also great to have for travelers as you can bring home your favorite hard-to-find coffee and still be able to use your Keurig. 

Keurig 1.0 is compatible with many third-party coffee pods as well. This provides endless automatic and pre-set options and allows you to easily experiment with different coffee styles. 

You don’t have to be a barista to use one of these either. The simple instructions and limited advanced options mean you can have a cup quickly whenever you want. This machine is preset with water temperature and brew-strength basic features to simplify the procedure.  

Who Benefits Most?

A Keurig 1.0 is great for household use. It’s great for a single cup of joe but can also make up to 10 cups of coffee at once. These machines are built for speed and convenience. All busy professionals love it for this and its choice in coffee pods. 

Being able to use third-party pods has proven to be a massive advantage with this machine. Those tired of buying a giant can of the same generic coffee grinds will really enjoy a Keurig 1.0.  

Best Of The 1.0s — K55

Even though there are less 1.0s to choose from, I found the K55 to separate itself from the other 1.0s. The thing that really grabbed my attention was the large reservoir. At 48oz, It has the capacity to brew up to six cups before a refill is needed. 

This also has an auto-brew function which not all 1.0s have. This is very popular amongst the weekly commuters as it’s one less thing to worry about in the morning when you’re rushing off to work. 

Lastly, I really like its simplicity both for controls and maintenance. The drip tray is removable so cleaning up quickly is no problem.

Pros

Simple operating instructions

Compatible with many third party pods

Affordable to a wide range of coffee drinkers

Includes a reusable K cup to use with your own beans

Can make up to 10 cups of coffee at a time

Indicator for when the brewing process is complete

Cons

Bulky and takes up countertop space

No control over water temperature settings or strength of coffee


Keurig 2.0

Released with mixed reviews, the Keurig 2.0 was highly anticipated. After changing the way, so many people started their day, it was inevitable that they would try to improve upon that further. 

The additional features are that it brews more at a time, and you have more control over your coffee. You can adjust the coffee brewing temperature to get your optimal extraction. You can also change the strength at which it will brew. 

This got many people excited; however, there was a drawback. 

Keurig Made A Huge Blunder

The Keurig 2.0 machines are only compatible with 2.0 pods. There is less selection when it comes to third-party pod options. If you stocked up on your favorite flavor and then wanted to switch to a 2.0, you had to finish your 1.0 pods first. 

This was not a popular strategy by Keurig, and they faced a lot of backlash for it

Aside from the K cups being different, this coffee maker model has a lot going for it. Besides having more control over the brewing process and being able to brew more, it’s also smaller than its predecessor. It takes up a lot less of your countertop, which is excellent for anyone in an apartment or those who like to cook. 

Who Benefits Most?

Coffee enthusiasts rushed to the stores so they could start brewing many different flavor profiles one cup at a time. Having this feature attracted a large populous of traditional coffee drinkers who weren’t entirely sold on the features of a Keurig 1.0. 

Giving this power to the consumer was a great idea, but, unfortunately, it did not benefit those with a stockpile of Keurig 1.0 pods. 

Best Of The 2.0s — K575

The K575 has all the great features of the 2.0. It’s a bit more hearty without being too large on your countertop. 

The reservoir is an enormous 80oz, allowing you to brew up to 10 cups of coffee before refilling. 

The bonus here is the hot water on-demand feature. For those who like to mix in a tea or hot chocolate, you can easily do so with the K575. It heats up water much faster than any tea kettle. 

The cleaning features are also made simple, and I love the colored touch screen. Selecting my coffee in the morning feels like I’m on the Starship Enterprise. 

Pros

Temperature control over water

Strength control setting

Makes up to 12 cups fast with use of the 4-cup carafe

Basic touch screen adds class to any kitchen

Takes up less space in your kitchen

Cons

Programmed to only work with K cups

Pricier


Keurig In Hot Water In The Media

This is one of those rare cases where “There’s no such thing as bad publicity” doesn’t apply. I’m sure Keurig wished people would just stop talking about the differences and just get back to loving their coffee and their coffee appliances. 

However, Pandora’s box has been opened, and with Keurig continuing with DRM technology, this conversation is far from over. 

Many have commented that Keurig is taking advantage of people who are already so loyal to them. This is the ‘hedge wall’ business model that all businesses want, but few get. 

On paper, selling the consumer a product that only functions with the use of more products from that same company sounds like a great idea. But sometimes, consumers are savvier or less willing to get tied down to one operation. That is the case here. 

Keurig faced a lot of public backlash for trying to corner its customers. The real salt on the wound is they had already released a generation of coffee makers that gave their customers freedom. It’s similar to when a new video game console comes out, and you have to buy all new games to go with it. 

While the Keurig 2.0 is discontinued, the digital rights management technology is not, and Keurig continues its quest to be your sole provider of coffee appliances and best-tasting coffee beans.  

The Best Flavors For A Keurig

These delicious flavors are all available in the 2.0 format and can be used in the older 1.0 models.

Green Mountain Coffee Breakfast BlendAs an excellent breakfast blend, it deserves the top spot to start your day on the right foot. This medium flavor is a low acid coffee to make it perfect for those early mornings. 

The Original Donut Shop CoffeeAnother excellent morning coffee; this one is a bit sweeter but maintains a silky coffee flavor that’s non-bitter. 

Crazy Cups Custom Variety PackYou can’t go wrong with a variety pack. Yes, you may run into some that are not enjoyable, but trial and error is half the fun with this enormous selection of K cups. 

Café Bustelo Espresso-Style Dark Roast Coffee K Cup PodsTest your Keurig’s range by enjoying a European-style cup of classy coffee. This dark roast is perfect for an afternoon pick me up. 

Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon RollReady to try something really fun, then grab a case of these. They taste just like a cinnamon roll and are just what the doctor ordered for those times you just need to put a smile on your face.  

FAQs

What is the biggest difference between the Keurig 1.0 and the Keurig 2.0?

The most significant difference between the Keurig 1.0 and the Keurig 2.0 is the K cup restrictions through barcode technology. The Keurig 2.0 is only compatible with Keurig branded cups specifically made for 2.0 machines. 1.0 cups will not work in a 2.0 machine. Keurig has since addressed this due to a more than expected public outcry. 

Does the Keurig 2.0 use the same K cups as the Keurig 1.0?

No, the Keurig 2.0 does not use the same K cups as the Keurig 1.0. The 2.0 uses its own specifically designed K cups. For those wanting to switch to a 2.0 from a 1.0, you will have to buy all new K cups or keep your 1.0 until you have finished them.  

Is the Keurig 2.0 easier to use than the Keurig 1.0?

No, the Keurig 2.0 is not easier to use than the Keurig 1.0. The Keurig 2.0 has a digital touch screen display that gives you control over your water temperature and the strength of your coffee. You can also brew in different volumes, which must also be set by the digital display. 

Is the Keurig 2.0 discontinued?

Yes, the Keurig 2.0 is discontinued. But Keurig still makes machines that are only compatible with their K cups. Their new machines contain an automatic brew function called digital rights management (DRM). This reads the top of your K cup and determines whether you bought it from Keurig or not. 

In Summary

I wanted to write this article to avoid confusion about how this generation of coffee makers work. It’s unfortunate that a company makes products that aren’t aligned with each other, but they aren’t the only ones to make this mistake. 

As long as you have all the information, you can get a K cup pod coffee maker that you’ll love. As a traveler, I prefer the 1.0’s because it allows me to bring home my own beans and sample bold coffee flavors from all over the world. Keurig is constantly releasing new shop blends, but there’s something satisfying about finding a fresh bean all by myself. 

The 2.0 is excellent for the added brewing features on a colored touch display, allowing more experimentation. Changing the water temperature or brew strength options on a Monday morning is sometimes just what we all need.

Unfortunately, Keurig won’t let us have our cake and eat it too. But for quick and hassle-free brewing, one cup of coffee at a time, the basic functions of these machines are incredible, and it’s no wonder they are so popular.

Further Read: Best Dual Coffee Machine

Photo of author
Author
Clint's skills as a barista have made it easy for him to transition into writing about coffee. With so much personal experience and passion, he is able to shed light on all aspects of coffee to ensure you can enjoy this delicious beverage as much as he does.

Save 15% on your next coffee order!

Readers of MyCoffeeBase now get the best deals on high-quality coffee from Bulletproof.com. Get 15% off whole beans, ground coffee, single-serve pods, and more. Click on the button below and use the discount code COFFEEBASE15 to claim the offer.

coffee beans